articles:linux_distribution_comparisons
This is an old revision of the document!
Table of Contents
Linux Distribution Comparisons
Personal Experiences
(Simono)
__Ubuntu 10.04__
This is the current(30/5/2010) version of Ubuntu (Gnome) 10.04.
- Installation was easy and straightforward, took less than 30 minutes.
- Upgrade can take several hours, potential warning messages pause upgrade, so it must be monitored to avoid wasting time
- Best to wait several days after issue, as bugs are often fixed in the first week.
- Relatively low footprint compared to Windows; a Vista-compatible system will have a scorching performance in comparison.
- One bug - if you use a resource-intensive screensaver, X sometimes crashes after extended periods. I keep it light.
- Long Term Support means it will be supported for 5 years, and directly upgradeable to 12.04 in the future.
- Comes with Open Office.
- Network printing via CUPS is the easiest of all I've tested to set up, including and especially Windows. Just click the right buttons.
- Hardware (currently): Core Duo 2.5 GHz each, 2 GB Ram, 320 GB HDD(SATA), also a HP 2133 netbook.
- Webcams work. With this hardware even Cheese can record video. Soon to be assisted(hopefully) by the planned PiTiVi Video Editor recording option.
__Fedora 13__
This is the current version of Fedora, an Open Source implementation from Red Hat.
- Installation was as easy as Ubuntu and as quick.
- Most of what the typical user will need (wireless, internet, email) will work straight away.
- It doesn't come with Open Office.
- It doesn't come with mp3 support. These both have to be added after modifying the software source repositories.
- Repository modification harder than Ubuntu.
- Depends on RPG modules not DEB.
- Installs via both YAM and APT.
- Online support is comparatively rare and often alpha-geeky.
- Personally, not an easy system to modify.
- Difficult to detect on a network, even harder to share with.
- Can 'see' Ubuntu shares, however.
- Unusually large footprint, 50GB 'root' partition out of a 250GB HDD.
- Familiarity in the Gnome desktop, similarities with Ubuntu 8.04-10.04.
- My installation disintegrated after four days, lost the volume control icon and could not detect any sound hardware.
- Every boot up generated a 'kernel crash' error report. Never seen one before anywhere.
- At boot-up, much frustration due to Username being displayed long before the machine was ready to allow login. A practical freeze-up.
- Shutdown is in two stages; you have to logout to get to a page where you can shut down. Spammy.
- Network printing with CUPS is trouble-free.
- Webcams appear to work, but my test hardware has never been able to support Cheese video recording. No change there.(Has to be said, XP can handle it on this hardware).
- Hardware spec: P4 2.36 GHz, 1.5 GB Ram, 250 GB PATA HDD.
__ SimplyMEPIS 8.5__
- Installation- I had to go to a Polish mirror, for straightforward downloads. Not well organised.
- Difficult. I tried to use the automatic reformat option for a default installation (over Fedora). It failed, and left behind a corrupted partition table.
- Fortunately, there is an excellent manual partitioner in the installer, practically the same as GPartedLive, which allowed me to rebuild the table, create a 5 GB root partition and leave the rest as an ext4 partition, a big one.
- Installation was smooth after this.
- Doesn't like legacy monitors much, but no actual faults, just a complaint on boot up.
- Setting up the wireless required a lot of fiddling with passwords, password managers and network managers, due to my inexperience with KDE.
- Support for mp3 already included.
- Repository management is easy, easier than Ubuntu.
- Amarok and Kaffeine needed to be installed for music and videos, but they worked well, straightaway. As usual, MPlayer was the not particularly good default.
- Support for Flash and Java was already installed on Firefox, even simpler than Ubuntu.
- Sometimes it will see Ubuntu shares right away, if not, the Ubuntu server can be added manually and it will see it.
- It is immediately visible and accessible from Ubuntu. Networking is fabulous.
- Webcams may be a problem; my E3500 didn't work with Kdenlive or Cheese, although it was detected. Installing VLC is not fun, I don't recommend it, as for one thing it will cause removal of Kdenlive.
- Skype is available and my webcam (E3500) worked immediately and well, both video and sound. Very good Skype.
- A beautiful look and feel.
- Brilliant screensavers, I have mine set to a huge 1970's BBC-style analogue clock.
- Network printing via CUPS is fairly straightforward.
- Cheap (£7) wireless dongle apparently gets a 75% signal strength now, as opposed to 50% with Fedora. The 'limo' option Belkin dongle gets 100%.
- Comes pre-loaded with Open Office, like Ubuntu.
- Tested on same hardware as Fedora.
(Terry)
__Kubuntu 10.04__
This is the current(30/5/2010) version of Kubuntu (KDE) 10.04.
- Initially I upgraded from 9.10, but I had various issues, most notably with display during startup.
- Then did a clean installation:
- This was easy and took about 30 minutes, although the updates afterwards took somewhat longer.
- I then had to reinstall all those packages that don't come as standard.
- I had a fully working system in around 70-80 mins with the residue of packages being installed as I needed them.
- Generally an improvement in terms of look-and-feel and performance over 9.10, due to the later version of KDE included.
- There are still problems though:
- I still cannot see the login menu. This has been discussed on the list and I only live with it because I only have this one distro on the machine.
- Occasionally, it freezes just after boot-up, with the Kubuntu 'dots' on the screen. Generally works after a reboot.
- It crashed big-time one day. I was writing a document in OpenOffice Writer and listening to a music track on Amarok, when the track started looping (just like the record had stuck). Everything else was dead. No mouse or keyboard responses, so I had to do a master reset. This is the first time I've had anything like this on Linux since the bad old days when graphics drivers and monitors didn't recognise each other; but they were always from boot-up.
- The defaults version of wine runs my only Windows App (Memory-Map), but still doesn't support one feature. I added the wine PPA and Memory-Map works perfectly now.
- Everything else I've tried works.
articles/linux_distribution_comparisons.1275229612.txt.gz · Last modified: 2010/05/30 15:26 by simono